Creative Approvals Flow
Proposal · Creative Content · myMabo · updated 16 Nov

Creative approvals, run from myMabo

One place for internal and client approval of every creative, from the designer saving a file to the AM putting it live. It brings together Carli's process, Adam's go-live rules and Dan's Creative Portal.

Clients, people and creatives on this page are examples.

Where the ideas come from

Carli · creative
  • A senior designer checks quality before the client sees anything
  • One sign-off contact per client, agreed at onboarding
  • Carli does the final check for Creative Retainer clients
Adam · social
  • Get approvals and go-live out of email and chat
  • AMs only get work once design and client have signed it off
  • AMs build everything, and mark it Built once it's in place
  • Not every design goes live straight away
Dan · Creative Portal
  • Designers just save to the client's Drive folder
  • "v2" in the file name makes a new version
  • One link per client, and a client page in the Mabo brand
  • Review panel with previews "as an ad" and a conversation per version
  • A "needs a reply" flag and days waiting for the team
  • Approval only: ad copy belongs to another team
The statuses
BATCH Draft→ Senior check→ With client⇄ Changes requested→ Final check→ Ready for AM
EACH CREATIVE, ONCE READY Builtor Held for later→ Live

One batch = one client's round of creative, such as "November prospecting refresh". Designers save the files to the client's Google Drive folder and myMabo picks them up. The client approves each creative separately. Once the batch is ready, the AM moves each creative on separately, because some will be used this month and others are kept for later.

Final check only happens for Creative Retainer clients. Everyone else goes straight from client approval to Ready for AM.

Two routes after the client approves

myMabo picks the route from the client's service, so nobody has to remember. Either way, the AM only gets the work once design and client have both signed it off.

Creative Retainer
  1. Designer saves to Drive
  2. Senior checks quality
  3. Client signs off
  4. Carli does the final check
  5. AM builds, or holds for later
All other clients
  1. Designer saves to Drive
  2. Senior checks quality
  3. Client signs off
  4. AM builds, or holds for later

Who does what

Click any step to see what happens, who gets told and what changes in ClickUp.

What it could look like in myMabo

Three screens. The first two are for staff. The third is the only one a client ever sees, and it works without a login.

my2.mabo.co.uk/creative/approvals

Creative approvals

Every open batch across clients. New files are picked up from Drive automatically.
3Client comments need a reply
2Waiting on senior check
3Waiting on client
3Ready for AM
ClientBatchChannelCreativesStatusProgressWaitingWith

What's been decided

Quality checkCarliA senior designer checks quality before anything goes to the client. Designing to the brief is the designer's responsibility.
When the AM gets itCarli, AdamOnly once design and the client have both signed it off. For Creative Retainer clients, Carli does a final check first.
Who buildsAdamAMs build everything: Klaviyo, Meta and Pinterest. They get a Ready notification and mark each creative Built, Held or Live, so go-live is never left to a chat message.
Client sign-offCarliOne sign-off contact (name and email), agreed on the onboarding call. If more people need to check, the client collects their feedback and sends it through that person.
How files get inDanDesigners save to the client's Drive folder, as they do today, and myMabo picks the files up. "v2" in a file name makes a new version, and a subfolder becomes a carousel. Nobody uploads anything twice.
Approval onlyDanClients approve the visuals. Ad copy belongs to another team, so the client page doesn't show or collect it.
FigmaCarli, DanNot needed for approvals, so there's no extra cost. Figma seats can be decided purely on whether they help with design work.
Client linkCarli, Adam, DanOne link per client that lasts as long as they're a client. Mabo can switch it off or replace it at any time. Mabo's terms put approval responsibility on the client, and the decision log shows exactly who approved what, and when.

Building on Dan's Creative Portal

Dan's portal (a Google Apps Script app using a Sheet, Drive and Gmail) worked out much of what the client side and the content team need. The proposal is to keep those ideas and rebuild them inside myMabo, where they sit with the rest of the process.

Carried over from the portal
  • Drive-folder pick-up, versions from file names, carousels from subfolders
  • The client page design: Mabo brand, "creatives need your attention", the three-column board and the month list
  • The review panel: previous and next, "Image only" or "As an ad", and approve, request changes or comment
  • A conversation per version, so v1 feedback stays visible next to v2
  • One link per client, a "creatives ready" email, and download approved work
  • For the team: a card grid with thumbnails, a "needs a reply" flag, days waiting and an all-clients view
What myMabo adds
  • The internal steps: senior check, Carli's final check, Ready for AM, Built, Held and Live
  • Each staff member logs in as themselves, so every action is recorded against a name
  • Batches tied to the client's record and service
  • ClickUp tasks kept up to date, plus Slack and myMabo notifications
  • Client data stays in myMabo's database, not in a shared spreadsheet

Build order

Each stage is useful on its own, so the team can start using it after stage 1.

Stage 1

Internal tracker

  • Each client linked to its Drive folder, with new files picked up automatically
  • Versions from file names and carousels from subfolders
  • Senior check, Carli's final check for Creative Retainer clients, then Ready for AM
  • AM marks each creative Built, Held (with a planned month) or Live
  • Team dashboard, a batch tab on each client's page, and ClickUp kept in sync
  • Card grid with thumbnails, a "needs a reply" flag and days waiting
  • Clients still approve by email for now, and the designer records the result
Stage 2

Client page

  • Dan's client design in the Mabo brand, on one link per client
  • Review panel with "As an ad" previews and a conversation per version
  • "Creatives ready" emails, download approved work, and a full record of every decision
Stage 3

Later, if useful

  • Confirm "Live" from Klaviyo, Meta or Pinterest instead of setting it by hand
  • A daily summary email for the content team
creative_batches        client_id, title, channel, status, drive_folder_id,
                        designer_id, senior_checker_id, final_checker_id, am_id,
                        signoff_name, signoff_email, clickup_task_id
creative_items          batch_id, title, format, sizes, is_carousel, version,
                        drive_file_id, build_notes, status (ready|built|held|live),
                        planned_month, built_at, live_at
creative_decisions      item_id, version, stage (senior|client|final),
                        decision, comment, decided_by, decided_at
creative_comments       item_id, version, author (staff user or client name),
                        body, needs_reply, created_at
creative_client_links   client_id, token_hash, revoked_at, last_opened_at

Table names are a first sketch. Decisions are only ever added, never changed, which gives a clear record of who approved what, at each stage.